0

Download your shortlist

Download All

Alfred McAlpine Capital Project Ltd v Tilebox Ltd (2006)

19 December 2005

Citation: EWHC 281 (TCC); [2005] B.L.R. 271; 104 Con. L.R. 39

Nature of case: Already reported in BLR, this case contains a useful review of the modern law on the distinction between liquidated damages and penalties. On the facts, the liquidated damages provision in the JCT WCD 1998 contract for £45,000 per week was a genuine pre-estimate of loss and the actual loss suffered by the developer, Tilebox, was higher.  The contractor therefore failed to obtain a declaration that the provision was a penalty. 

See other reports: BLR 271 TCC

Link to full judgement.